The Dolphin Game: Tips and Tricks for Hyperscanning with Children

2 min read

Note: The following article is a guest post by Vanessa Reindl from University Hospital RWTH Aachen, Germany. She made our original hyperscanning game more interesting for children studies. She is very generous for sharing her experience as well as the game itself.

Vanessa Reindl

Planning our first hyperscanning study, we were looking for a task to measure the parent’s and child’s ability to synchronize their behavioral responses. In addition, the task should be able to control for confounds, such as seeing the same stimuli and performing the same actions. We were excited about the study by Dr. Xu Cui and his colleagues and piloted the cooperative and competitive games with children. Unfortunately, the games were a bit too difficult for young children. Therefore, we adapted the games (the “dolphin game”). Our goal was to keep the tasks’ structure as close as possible to the original games but to make them more appealing for children. Further, we wanted to simplify the feedback and keep it very intuitive without using words or numbers so that no reading skills are required. We have so far used the dolphin games in three studies (Reindl et al., 2018; Kruppa et al., 2021; Reindl et al., 2021) with children aged between 5 years and 18 years, who played the games with (one of) their parents and unfamiliar adults.

Dolphin games: The two participants each play a dolphin. During cooperation, the task is to catch a ball together and win shared points by reacting (button press) as simultaneously as possible. During competition, the task is to catch the ball and win a point for oneself by reacting faster than the other player.

  • Cooperation: In each trial, a black circle appears on the screen above the dolphins. After 0.6-1.5s, the black circle is replaced by a colorful ball (‘go’ signal). The participants are instructed to press their computer keys after the ‘go’ signal. If the difference between their response times is below a threshold, both dolphins jump to the ball, catch the ball together and win a point. If it is above the threshold, only the faster dolphin jumps to the ball, none of the dolphins catches the ball and both lose a point. Based on this feedback, the participants can adapt their response time in the next trial.
  • Competition: The task structure is similar to the cooperative game, except that the participant who presses the key faster will catch the ball and win a point (and the other will lose a point).

As in the original games by Xu and his colleagues, each game consists of two task blocks with 20 trials each and three 30s rest blocks in alternating order. While the games are very similar to the original games, there are some things which should be considered when doing the experiment with children:

Tip 1: Check task behavior and performance

Prior to running the study, check the percentage of joint wins during cooperation, child wins and adult wins during competition to see whether the difficulty level is right. You may change the win threshold for cooperation in case the game is too easy or too difficult. Further, you may check whether the participants successfully adapt their reaction times during cooperation and do so more strongly than during competition. One option is to look at how the difference in reaction times between adult and child changes after receiving feedback on who reacted faster (for cooperation this is only the case in trials in which participants lost a point). Do reaction times become more similar during cooperation after receiving feedback? If this is the case, this is a good validity check and indicates that the participants have understood the task (see Reindl et al., 2021).  

Tip 2: Check data quality

Obtaining a good fNIRS signal quality can be more challenging in young children than in adults. In particular, preschool children may have more difficulty sitting still for long periods of time and motion artifacts are generally more prevalent in the data. This can be addressed in the data analysis stage, but unfortunately, artifact correction techniques cannot fully replace a good data quality. Therefore, already when piloting the experiment, check the data quality and think about ways to improve it. For this experiment, one effective possibility may be to use chin rests (see Jove video).

Tipp 3: Cooperation and competition may elicit emotions

Cooperating and competing with the parents or unfamiliar adults may elicit emotions, such as joy or frustration, and accompanying emotional arousal (imagine losing against the parent!). Such changes in the autonomic nervous system can also affect the fNIRS signal. One possibility to deal with this is to measure the participant’s arousal using simultaneous electrocardiography recordings synchronized to the fNIRS recordings (see Reindl et al., 2021).

If you would like to try out the Dolphin games, please feel free to write an email to vreindl@ukaachen.de for the Matlab scripts and stay tuned for a parallel version of the game, which we are currently developing with monkeys instead of dolphins.

第二十三期 fNIRS Journal Club 通知 2021/09/25,10:00am

上海师范大学的张明明博士将为大家介绍团体 (三人或者之上) 超扫描领域的进展,以及他们最近发表的团体超扫描决策行为的文献。热烈欢迎大家参与讨论。 时间: 北京时间2021年9月25日上午10:00地点: https://zoom.com房间号: 894 6339 2399 密码: 264149 张博士要讲解的文章如下: Zhang, Jia, Wang (2021) Interbrain Synchrony of Team Collaborative Decision-Making: An fNIRS...
Xu Cui
9 sec read

第二十二期 fNIRS Journal Club 视频

北京时间2021年8月28日10:00,美国南卡罗来纳大学心理学系的符晓雪博士,为大家讲解她刚刚发表在Neurophotonics上的一篇文章,用NIRS研究发育过程中头皮和大脑关系的变化。https://www.storkapp.me/pubpaper/34322572 Youtube: https://youtu.be/49wmBv1d2TE Youku 优酷:上传后被屏蔽,未知原因。 相关资源: 文献鸟(追踪科学文献)文献大分析(两分钟了解一个领域)
Xu Cui
4 sec read

第二十二期 fNIRS Journal Club 通知 2021/08/28,10:00am

美国南卡罗来纳大学心理学系的符晓雪博士,将为大家讲解她刚刚发表在Neurophotonics上的一篇文章,用NIRS研究发育过程中头皮和大脑关系的变化。热烈欢迎大家参与讨论。 时间: 北京时间2021年8月28日上午10:00地点: https://zoom.com房间号: 845 7541 3964密码: 829803 符晓雪博士是南卡罗来纳大学心理学系的博士后研究员。 她在宾夕法尼亚州立大学获得发育心理学博士学位。 她的博士后工作重点是 fNIRS 和 ERP 的皮层源定位方法。 符博士要讲解的文章如下: Fu, Richards (2021) Investigating developmental changes in scalp-to-cortex...
Xu Cui
6 sec read

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *